The Yellowstone spinoff 1883 certainly has fans talking, especially now that the original series has wrapped up its fourth season. While there has been some discussion from showrunner Taylor Sheridan over the fact that he doesn’t think his shows are critical darlings, what have critics said about the first season of 1883 so far?
The prequel series stars Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, and Sam Elliott, and It currently has a Rotten Tomatoes critics score of 84%, meaning it’s certified fresh. Popculture.com rated the show highly. “There are some wild moments, gripping action and slow moments that let our characters get emotional and breathe without things getting too dry,” the review read. “This is a show I’m interested in watching more of: tempers rising over routes, clashes on how to handle a massive group of travelers, intimate family moments and some great acting throughout it all.”
Videos by PopCulture.com
High Praise
Most critics are ready to take a ride with 1883. “Thanks to a compelling plot and a robust cast of characters, the dramatic Western creates an entertaining chronicle that’s easy to get caught up in,” read the Common Sense Media review. “Two episodes in, and I genuinely can’t stop thinking about it,” wrote Dustin Rowles for Pajiba.
A Worthy Spinoff
Critics also thought 1883 was good enough to stand on its own outside of Yellowstone. “A brilliant Yellowstone prequel that portrays an era of open spaces, constant dangers,” wrote the Chicago-Sun Times. “1883 hits all the right notes as an absorbing piece of fiction,” wrote the New York Post.
The Brutal American West
Vanity Fair also had positive things to say about 1883. “Strap down your Stetson, ’cause it’s a grim, bumpy ride… This isn’t just the Duttons’ traumatic origin story; in many ways, it’s the American West’s, too,” they wrote. Many critics pointed out Elliott as the show’s expected standout. “We’re concerned about the pacing of 1883 and how it depicts Indigenous people, but the story is compelling, and Sam Elliott’s multi-layered lead performance is more than enough to keep us interested,” wrote Decider.
Narrative Scope
Other critics pointed out the massive scope of 1883 and how it even outpaced Yellowstone itself. “1883 has the characters, the scope, and the vision to become an exciting new chapter of the Yellowstone franchise, as well as a rare example of a spin-off that never feels beholden to its source material,” wrote Variety. The AV Club called it an “unflinching look at the beginnings of Yellowstone‘s Dutton family.”
Some Naysayers
However, not everyone is on board with 1883. “An opportunity to disrupt present-day comprehension of a transformative period in U.S. history is wasted on yet another narrative from the point of view of white settlers,” pointed out IndieWire. CNN was similarly harsh, writing that “for fans of westerns, 1883 certainly looks like the real deal, coming from Yellowstone creator Taylor Sheridan and featuring Sam Elliott as a gnarled cowboy. The execution, however, feels stale.” The Hollywood Reporter wrote “I can’t emphasize enough how much unearned credibility the series gets from Elliott’s performance.” 1883’s first three episodes are currently streaming on Paramount+, with following installments premiering each Sunday.
More TV Shows
-

โReverse the Curseโ โ Back from tribal, tensions rise following the exit of a particularly historic player. The final five immunity challenge ends in a showdown and features one of the closest finishes the show has ever seen. Jeff reveals the outcomes of the remaining in-game fan votes and how they impact the final stage of the competition. Then, one castaway will be crowned Sole Survivor and awarded the $2 million prize, during the three-hour live season finale, on SURVIVOR 50, Wednesday, May 20 (8:00-11:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on-demand for Paramount+ Premium plan subscribers, or on-demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)*. Jeff Probst serves as host and executive producer. Pictured: Aubry Bracco Photo: Robert Voets/CBS ยฉ2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved. -

โA Side Dish of Chaosโ โ One castaway comes clean to the tribe about a previously deceptive move. The crowd favorite SURVIVOR auction returns, with an extra special season 50 spin. Chaos ensues when social media icon MrBeast arrives on the scene, on SURVIVOR 50, Wednesday, April 29 (8:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT). Photo: Robert Voets/CBS ยฉ2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.






