The Olympian and pro partner Sasha Farber were sent home after earning a 24/30 for their cathartic tango to "Shame" by Elle King.
Model Alexis Ren and pro partner Alan Bersten (who may be in a showmance!) were also in jeopardy at the end of the night, after earning a 27/30 from the judges for their fun-filled jazz number to "Candyman" by Christina Aguilera.
Here's how the rest of the teams stacked up on Halloween night:
Country radio personality Bobby Bones and pro partner Sharna Burgess received a 22/30 for their steamy Argentine tango to "Mr. Sandman" by SYML.
NFL pro DeMarcus Ware, still recovering from a dislocated finger, and his pro partner Lindsay Arnold were awarded a 26/30 for their "breakthrough" salsa to "Under Your Spell" by Leo Soul.
Harry Potter actress Evanna Lynch and pro Keo Motsepe earned a 29/30 for their "fierce" tango to "Disturbia" by Rihanna.
The Bachelorette alum Joe "Grocery Store Joe" Amabile and pro Jenna Johnson took home a season high score of 22/30 from the judges following their "best ever" Argentine tango to "El Tango de Roxanne" from Moulin Rouge.
Dukes of Hazzard actor John Schneider and pro partner Emma Slater were awarded a 19/30 for their error-filled paso doblé to "Main Titles" from Beetlejuice, performed live by Ray Chew.
Fuller House actor Juan Pablo Di Pace and pro partner Cheryl Burke received a 30/30 for their "perfect" jive to "Dead Man's Party" by the Atwater Men's Club.
Zombies actor Milo Manheim and Witney Carson took home a perfect 30/30 for their "creepy" contemporary number to "Toxic" by 2WEI.
In last week's Disney-themed episode, Ren and Bertsten and Lynch and Motsepe were both declared to be in jeopardy of going home, but were saved by a bit of Disney magic when it was revealed there would be no elimination that night. But it is clear there is no saving those whose score/vote combinations don't stack up now!
Who will be going home next week?
Dancing With the Stars airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.
Photo Credit: ABC