Sex and the City revival And Just Like That… may only be three seasons in, but fans have already spotted a glaring plot hole.
A recent episode of the HBO Max drama killed off Lisa Todd Wexley’s father, only it already happened back in Season 1.
Videos by PopCulture.com
In “Silent Mode,” Lisa (Nicole Ari Parker) tells Kristin Davis’ Charlotte over the phone that her father passed away after having a stroke “out of nowhere.” However, back in Season 1, Lisa mentioned that she lost her dad the previous year. Fans commented on a TikTok video highlighting the two scenes in which Lisa mentions her father’s passing, and they were pretty ruthless, with one hilariously saying, “And just like that he was dead again.”
User cha_cha_p wrote, “Don’t forget he was already passed in season 1, and came for dinner in season 2, and now he is gone again… not everyone gets that kind of second chance.” Matcha&dogs, meanwhile, suggested a scenario that would be quite the plot twist, “spoiler: they are all dead, it’s a nightmare.”
Apparently, it’s not quite the unexpected plot hole that fans think. A source close to the series told TheWrap that Lisa’s stepfather died prior to the first season, while her biological dad recently passed from a stroke. The series hasn’t made any mention of that being the case, but it’s not entirely impossible for that to be the case. It’s definitely a lot better than writers already forgetting a major plot point only three seasons in, but for now, fans will just have to weigh in with their own thoughts.
Despite the plot hole, fans can’t stop watching And Just Like That… The series premiered in 2021, with numerous Sex and the City stars reprising their roles, including Sarah Jessica Parker, Cynthia Nixon, and Kristin Davis. Season 3 premiered on May 29 and is set to air through Aug. 14. Whether there will be more plot holes is unknown, but fans will just have to wait and see. If Season 4 is ordered, it will also be interesting to see if the show manages to bring back Lisa’s dad once again, but if it truly was just stepfather and biological father, then the writers deserve the benefit of the doubt.
New episodes of And Just Like That… drop on Thursdays on HBO Max.
Most Viewed
-
Side-by-side: Images of Tim Allen, Stefan Gossler and Jackie Chan (Credit: Christian JENTZ/Gamma-Rapho // Franziska Krug/Getty Images // Stephane Cardinale/Corbis) -
A defocused police car sits behind crime scene tape with flashing lights at night. (Getty Images/iStockphoto) -
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA – JANUARY 20: Bijou Phillips attends the World Premiere of "Infinite Icon: A Visual Memoir" at AMC The Grove 14 on January 20, 2026 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/FilmMagic) -
Netflix logo (Credit: Netflix) -
Beverly Hills, CA – January 31, 2026: Jelly Roll, left, and Bunnie Xo, right, pose for portraits on the red carpet during the 68th GRAMMY Awards Pre-GRAMMY Gala & GRAMMY Salute to Industry Icons Honoring Avery Lipman & Monte Lipman at the Beverly Hilton on Saturday, Jan. 31, 2026 in Beverly Hills, CA. Clive Davis’ annual pre-Grammy party hosts an array of A-listers from entertainment, sports, and politics to come together and enjoy performances. (Kayla Bartkowski/ Los Angeles Times) -
WINDSOR, UNITED KINGDOM – APRIL 20: (EMBARGOED FOR PUBLICATION IN UK NEWSPAPERS UNTIL 24 HOURS AFTER CREATE DATE AND TIME) Prince Andrew, Duke of York attends the traditional Easter Sunday Mattins Service at St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle on April 20, 2025 in Windsor, England. (Photo by Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Images) -
PARK CITY, UTAH – JANUARY 25: Brandi Glanville attends the PBM Princess x Kemo Sabe red carpet event special screening of Rachel Strauss’ Documentary "Side Effects May Include” during Sundance Film Festival on January 25, 2026 in Park City, Utah. (Photo by Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images for Rachel Strauss)
