King Charles' Striking Royal Portrait Divides the Public
The new portrait has some fans seeing red.
British Pundits
Generally speaking, British pundits on the news and on social media called this painting disrespectful, technically unimpressive and just plain "ugly." Piers Morgan and his panel compared the painting to, among other things, a menstrual cycle, engaging in the public discussion but ultimately dismissing it fairly quickly.
Negative Reviews
Art critic Jonathan Jones wrote a one-star review of this portait for The Guardian, calling it a "formulaic bit of facile flattery." Jones writes that he likes Yeo as a person and found him charming on his press tour surrounding this painting, but the work itself left him wanting. Jones noted that he did not care for Yeo's previous work either, and he found the inclusion of "monarch butterflies" to be superficial and impersonal.
Another negative review written by Sebastian Smee for The Washington Post calls the portrait "frightening," and an "assault" on the eyes. He wrote that there were "so many decisions avoided" in the creation of this painting, explaining: ""Do we want pretty or gritty? Abstract or figurative? Symbolism (note the butterfly, standing for Charles's transformation from prince into king) or realism? Illusion of spatial depth or a flat, all-over effect? Dignified royal reserve or palpable collapse into pathos? It's all there. A heap of oxymorons, a pileup of platitudes."
Positive Reviews
![King Charles first official portrait since coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo King Charles first official portrait since coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo](https://sportshub.cbsistatic.com/i/2024/05/21/43c74dc3-69fe-401b-b1e0-8880b277e74b/king-charles-portrait-closeup-getty.jpg?auto=webp&width=1200&height=800&crop=1.5:1,smart)
LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM – MAY 16: Close-up view of King Charles' first official portrait since the coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo on public display at Philip Mould Gallery in central London, Britain, May, 16, 2024. The painting about 8ft 6in by 6ft 6in in size shows King Charles in the uniform of the Welsh Guards. The painting will be on display until 14 June and will go on display in Drapers' Hall from the end of August. (Photo by Stringer/Anadolu via Getty Images)
- Anadolu)Simon Collins' positive review of the portrait for The Nightly begins with the caveat: "I'm no fan of the royal family, in fact, i despise everything monarchies stand for. However, I love the first official portrait of King Charles." Collins praises the painting's "clobber" of color, which he feels "fades into crimson brushstrokes" as you look at it.
More importantly to Collins, he praised Yeo for embracing the controversial response to his painting. He felt that it was a positive change for an artist to make a bold statement with this kind of portrait now that monarchs do not possess the unilateral power to punish them with violence. He wrote that Yeo's works "care little for their subject's self-regard but connect to deeper truths."
Conspiracy Theories
On social media, you'll find plenty of posts from users who thought that this painting was meant to imply that the king is in hell, or is drenched in blood, or other existential connotations. These are valid as interpretations of art, but are not meaningful evidence to support any conspiracy theories.
Media References
![King Charles first official portrait since coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo King Charles first official portrait since coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo](https://sportshub.cbsistatic.com/i/2024/05/21/d4193b45-da3e-4812-966e-d8a74214ec86/king-charles-portrait-selfie-getty.jpg?auto=webp&width=1200&height=800&crop=1.5:1,smart)
LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM – MAY 16: A man takes a selfie with King Charles' first official portrait since the coronation painted by Jonathan Yeo on public display at Philip Mould Gallery in central London, Britain, May, 16, 2024. The painting about 8ft 6in by 6ft 6in in size shows King Charles in the uniform of the Welsh Guards. The painting will be on display until 14 June and will go on display in Drapers' Hall from the end of August. (Photo by Stringer/Anadolu via Getty Images)
- Anadolu)Others got to work comparing this painting to recognizable scenes from movies and TV shows – it reminded some of the bloody elevator scene from The Shining, and made others think of the villain from Ghostbusters 2, and so on.
Memes
Finally, the painting's unveiling brought out some unique new memes as users pasted into scenes from video games, viral images and other self-referential works. They also meticulously copied fictional characters or other people into the portrait, or even themselves. The chatter died down quickly, but it's clear that this painting made a big impression on some viewers.