Disney Fans Blast Classic Movie as 'Not for Children'
In retrospect, many fans wonder if 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame' is really suitable for a young audience.
'Not for Children'
We tried to watch it at some point last year and I had forgotten that it literally opens with the attempted murder of a disabled baby, I have NO idea how this one got past anyone, it is so much not for children 😬
— Alyssa Long 🦖🥄 ♿️🥄 (@MeasuredAndSlow) September 13, 2023
Many viewers reported their surprise when revisiting this movie as adults with their own children. They found the subject matter itself to be too upsetting for the intended age group.
prevnextOutrageous Pitch
I really want to know who thought making this book into a kids’ movie was a good idea anyway. That’s like “Let’s make Les Mis into a kids’ movie!”
— Shannon Brescher Shea (@storiteller) September 15, 2023
Knowing how movies are made, many commenters wondered how this one even got past the pitch process, considering the odd pairing of the source material with the target audience.
prevnextStill Love It
It is a good movie though, I love the music (and Pheebus, don't tell anyone >.> )
— windriderz49 (@windriderz49) September 13, 2023
The movie's die-hard fans did not try to defend it, but made it clear that they were glad it got made, even if it was a fluke of some kind.
prevnextDefenders
This is true... a lot of Disney movie things aren't geared towards the kids or things they would understand. Right over their heads lol
— windriderz49 (@windriderz49) September 13, 2023
On the other hand, some commenters did genuinely defend the movie, saying that children shouldn't be completely shielded from unpleasant things – especially in the safe context of a movie.
prevnextCorruption
Monsters Inc is rated G. A movie about monsters scaring kids is rated G. So I looked it up. And of course it is because Disney paid for the ratings
— Sara (@Banner1107) September 13, 2023
the first disney animated movie to have a pg rating was "the black cauldron" in 1985, and there wasn't another pg rating until 2002, for "lilo & stitch". hunchback came at a time where disney was attempting a shift towards adult themes. lion king absolutely impacted this rating
— 🕳️ The 💖Barbie💖 In The Pit 🕳️ (@pontaneously) September 13, 2023
Of course, many people theorized that there had to be some kind of corruption between the MPAA and Disney. For a studio this big, they figured the lines of communication would be open.
prevnextOther Examples
I recently rewatched Anastasia too and it is DARK
— Cora Harrington (@lingerie_addict) September 13, 2023
Commenters discussed other examples of surprisingly dark children's movies, including Fox's Anastasia.
prevnextRemake
Absolutely
— Beatrice Bella (@BeatriceBella16) September 13, 2023
Finally, with Disney working on so many live-action remakes these days, some fans wondered when this one would get a more mature treatment.
prev