Christie Brinkley Reveals the Pick-Up Line She's Fallen for 'Four Times'

07/02/2016 09:31 pm EDT

We're pretty sure supermodel Christie Brinkley has heard her fair share of pick-up lines, but on the latest episode of PEOPLE's List, the model revealed which one she actually fell for — four times!

To celebrate her new line of Prosecco, called Bellissima, the icon headed to her favorite bar in Manhattan, Drexler's, where mixologists made her some Prosecco-based drinks and asked her a few hard-hitting questions.

One of those hilarious questions was: "What's your favorite pick-up line?," and while Brinkley's answer wasn't standard, it was definitely familiar to her!

"Will you marry me?," she jokingly responded. "I fell for it four times."

Brinkley, 62, has been married four times — to Francois Allaux (1973–81), Billy Joel (1985–94), Richard Taubman (1994–95), and Peter Cook (1996–2008), PEOPLE details, and has three children — Alexa Ray Joel, 30, and Jack and Sailor Cook, 21 and 18 respectively.

During the interview, she also dished on her preferred drinking time and favorite food — she's a sucker for some good mozzarella, among other things! Hear her perfect answers in the video above!

Disclosure: PopCulture. is owned by Paramount. Sign up for Paramount+ by clicking here.